
A couple of months ago, I wrote a
review of I Am Legend, the book. Over the weekend, Laura and I were able to see the movie with Will Smith.
The movie wasn't all that bad. I really liked the visuals of New York torn apart by the virus. The flashbacks were well-done, showing a lot of what had happened with the world before everything went to pot.
But in the end, I have to say I was a little disappointed. Had I not read the book, certainly I would have liked the movie more, but like many things, the book was better than the movie.
In the book, the vampire/zombie things were a lot more interesting. They weren't just mindless monsters running after their kill. Some of them talked, and they had a plan. They knew where the main character was (though there were reasons they could not reach him), and they taunted him night after night.
Researching the virus felt more real in the book as well. We were able to follow through from one step to another and see how he was able to piece together what he learned about the virus through understandable break-throughs. In the movie, we're introduced to him with a full laboratory and doing blood tests and the like right off. Nothing showing him working at it and what pains he goes through just to learn more.
I think I did like the dog better in the movie than I did in the book, mostly because it was such a small part of the book - a dog that the main character finds and tries to befriend. In the book the dog is more of a springboard to show the desolation and loneliness the main character feels.
I also really liked the scene in the movie where he goes to the video store with all the manikins and the conversations he has with them. A nice touch to show how he's trying to cope with everything.
But I think my biggest criticism of the movie has to be the ending. I don't want to give away the ending of either, so I'll just say that the end of both comes down to the title, "I Am Legend", and each one takes it in a drastically different direction. The book, I think does it far better.
Ah, what the heck, I'll spoil it.
If you don't want to know the ending of the book and movie, skip the rest of this post until you see the next picture.Okay, now that's out of the way. The movie ended with Will Smith finding the cure, giving it to another human he found, and sacrificing his life to make sure they could escape with the cure. The end is a voice-over by the woman who got the cure from Will Smith as she says that the oncoming society that his cure is going to allow to exist is his legacy, and he will become a legend for bringing it about, essentially.
The book's ending is a bit different than that. He does find another person, but it turns out the person is a vampire who has found a way to control her appetite for blood and the like. She escapes from him and heads back to a society that the "enlightened" vampires are building. They end up capturing him and taking him back with them. He is given poison by the woman he had met earlier because, she tells him, the other vampires will never let him go now. They have become civilized and are the new society that is coming out of the old one. They're taking care of all the feral vampires and starting anew. The "I Am Legend" part comes from the main character's last thoughts as he looks out of his cell windows over the new society that's forming. People are looking at him frightened and he realizes that he is a monster to them. They cannot go out during the day, and during the entire book, he would hunt them when they are most vulnerable and kill them when they could not try to stop him. He killed hundreds of them in his time, and realizes that he became their boogie man. As he dies, he realizes that like vampires and the like for us, he will become the legend of their new society.
A bit more depressing, to be sure, but still, I like the book's ending better.

No spoilers in this one. The second post apocalyptic movie that Laura and I saw this weekend was The Road, also based on a book.
If you want to be depressed, see the Road. Or better yet, read it.
This one's a story about a father and his son as they travel through the end of the world. Like "I Am Legend", there are some things shown in flashback, but they don't really have anything to do with why the world is the way it is. They have to do only with the characters.
The entire story is built on these two characters and them trying to not only survive, but maintain the will to survive as they go. It's a f-ed up world. Food is scarce. Most of the animals and plants are dead. There's a scene where the kid and his father find a house where they can take a bath, and when they take their shirts off, they are disgustingly thin. Ribs poking out and everything.
There is a lot of talk in the movie about good guys and bad guys, and the father keeps talking about how they're the good guys. They don't resort to cannibalism, and they don't hunt people. But as the movie goes on, you realize how much humanity the father has lost just trying to keep his son alive. And the sad thing is I think the son realizes it too. It's a sad story, and never really picks up. There is no beginning, really, and the end's not really an end either. It's a small section of their life and showing the struggles to keep alive in the world the way it became.
Overall, I'd recommend the Road, but only for a time when you're ready for the story to depress you. It's a bit slow, but does a great job of drawing you in to the emotion of the world as it is.